It’s Cyber Monday over at Tindie, and to celebrate, we’re taking 20% off nearly everything just for today. So now’s a great time to get a Re:load, some Circuit Patterns Trading Cards or a MiniMatrix to call your own!
By now, you’re probably aware that every compliant USB device requires a Vendor ID (VID) and Product ID (PID), and that VIDs are handed out - in return for substantial monetary compensation - exclusively by the USB-IF. This has proven problematic for open source hobbyists and small electronics businesses for a long time, since the fees they demand are well outside what’s affordable for a small project or a hobby. I’ve had a pet theory on how to resolve this for a while, though, and recently I decided to see if it could really work.
My idea was this: While USB-IF prohibits resale of PIDs, they don’t - or at least didn’t until recently, see below - prohibit handing out PIDs for limited use for free, as witnessed by organisations like Microchip and FTDI who hand out PIDs for use on their hardware, or by OpenMoko, who hand out PIDs on their VID to open source users. Therefore, perhaps a not-for-profit foundation could be formed, solicit donations for a VID, and hand out PIDs free of charge to anyone who meets the criteria. Such a foundation could also reserve a few PIDs for ‘generic’ devices that expose a well defined set of endpoints, enabling drivers for such to be produced and qualified with MS.
I decided to see if this was as practical as I thought it would be. Unfortunately, USB-IF have recently increased their fee to $5000 US, and updated their Vendor ID agreement(PDF) to include the following text:
The company set forth above hereby applies for a USB Vendor ID Number and agrees to the following: The USB Implementers Forum is the authority which assigns and maintains all USB Vendor ID Numbers. Each Vendor ID Number is assigned to one company for its sole and exclusive use, along with associated Product ID Numbers. They may not be sold, transferred, or used by others, directly or indirectly, except in special circumstances, and then only upon prior written approval by USB-IF. Unauthorized use of assigned or unassigned USB Vendor ID Numbers and associated Product ID Numbers are strictly prohibited.
Not great - but there’s still that “special circumstances” and “prior written approval” bit. So I sent the USB-IF a very polite letter enquiring about the possibility:
I’m interested in licensing a VID from the USB-IF explicitly for the purpose of enabling small developers producing open source hardware to more easily produce USB devices.
Tentatively, this would involve establishing a not for profit foundation, whose members are allocated PIDs from a VID owned by the foundation. Membership would be free of charge, and PIDs would not be charged for either. PIDs would not be available to anyone outside the foundation, or anyone producing hardware that is not open source; if needed additional restrictions on number of units could be imposed. These amount to similar or more restrictive terms as those followed by FTDI and Microchip, who provide PIDs to users of their hardware.
Are you prepared to license a VID along these lines? A great deal of the open source and OSHW community would benefit from being able to more easily produce USB devices on a small scale, one not currently catered for by the issuing of VIDs to larger organisations.
Arachnid Labs Ltd
A few hours later, I got a response:
Thank you for your message. The USB VID is the property of the USB Implementers Forum (“USB-IF”) and is assigned by the USB-IF for use solely by the original vendor to whom the VID is issued. The VID is provided to the assigned company to identify only its own products and neither the VID nor associated PIDs may be sublicensed, transferred or offered for resale in any manner.
The policy of the USB-IF regarding vendor ID numbers (VIDs) is as stated in the attached policy statement. In general, VIDs are not transferable.
The USB-IF has long had a VID/PID process for hobbyists.
Please immediately cease and desist raising funds to purchase a unique USB VID for the purpose of transferring, reselling or sublicensing PIDs and delete all references to the USB-IF, VIDs and PIDs for transfer, resale or sublicense from your website and other marketing materials.
Please kindly reply no later than Friday, October 25 with your written assurance that you will no longer promote the purchase of a community VID or PIDs for sale, transfer, or use by a third party.
I’ll leave it to you to judge if that seems proportional. Regardless, the message is clear: No VIDs for you.
If anyone knows what the USB-IF’s VID/PID process for hobbyists is, I’d like to hear it. I’ll ask them for details and update this post if I receive one.
Update: USB-IF’s response about the ‘hobbyist process’:
We do have a vendor ID number designated for prototype products. This vendor ID number may not be used for a production product. Anybody who has such a need may contact us directly and we will provide them with the proto VID once they confirm that will not be making production products to be distributed and/or sold in the marketplace.
Best regards, Traci
Interesting to know - I’d certainly never heard that this was an option - but it doesn’t seem to be a practical option for those of us who sell our gear in small quantities, but it might work if you want to publish your design as OSHW for other people to build themselves.
Coming from a software background to electronics, I tend to try and apply tools and techniques I learned in one to the other. Some skills and approaches transfer very well, while others don’t. One that seems to transfer very well is the technique of looking at schematics in terms of design patterns.
Design patterns are quite common in software, and provide an easy way to break down a system into components that you already understand, rather than trying to understand the system as one large piece. Happily, you can take much the same approach to analyzing, understanding, and composing electronic circuits - and once you start to learn common patterns, understanding an unfamiliar circuit becomes a great deal simpler!
An example ought to make this clearer. Here’s the equivalent schematic for a simple operational amplifier, courtesy of Wikipedia:
Complicated, right? But it gets a lot easier to understand when you know how to break it up into its constituent parts, and recognise the repeating patterns:
In this annotated image, current mirrors are outlined in red, a differential amplifier in blue, voltage level shifter in green, and an output stage in cyan. Each of these are components that can be understood independent of each other, and you’ll see them repeated again and again in different designs. Some of them can be broken down further into sub-patterns, too!
Or, how about a simpler example. Here’s an excerpt from the Arduino Uno schematic, the part that controls switching between USB and DC plugpack power:
And here it is, annotated to show the patterns, simple though they are:
Here, the blue box depicts a voltage divider, the green a comparator, and the red a FET switch.
This doesn’t just apply to analog circuits, either - you’ll find common patterns in digital, in power electronics, in fact pretty much everywhere there’s human designers at work. Most people learn to recognize them implicitly, and certainly there are a number of them that get taught as such. Everyone knows what a resistor divider does, for instance, or learns it pretty quickly.
I think there’s a lot of value in using patterns as a teaching tool directly, though, and once I sat down with the explicit goal of identifying and describing patterns, it wasn’t hard to find a lot of them. I thought it would be very neat to print them off on cards; I could publish the source online, and include one in each Arachnid Labs package I sent out.
It didn’t take long to pick out 32 patterns, ranging from the extremely common and well known, to the more advanced or esoteric - a collection I hope will have something in it for everyone. I got a few printed by Moo, and took them with me to my first Mini Maker Faire, at Elephant and Castle.
Here’s a few example cards. The ubiquitous resistor divider, of course:
Or how about a capacitative voltage doubler, from power electronics:
If digital’s more your style, there’s the SR latch:
As you can see, each card is color coded by type, and has a schematic and a short description of its functionality, along with relevant equations and other information.
At the Maker Faire, they were popular beyond my wildest imagination. People weren’t content with just one - they wanted whole decks! I wasn’t really prepared for this, but after the faire, I sought out a small run printing service and got my own decks with tuckboxes made. Now they’re even being resold by Adafruit!.
As with everything else produced by Arachnid Labs, the full source is available on GitHub. The source files are all HTML, rendered using wkpdf - apologies to anyone using Linux or Windows, though I’m certain alternatives will work with a little tweaking. The schematics are all exported from Eagle using a script that’s part of the makefile.
Of course, if you’d just like a set for yourself without all the hassle, they’re available on Tindie, too.
Do you have a favorite electronics pattern that you’d like to see explained better? I’m pondering expansion decks focused on specific fields such as digital, power and analog, and I’d love to hear what patterns you think warrant going in one. Leave a note in the comments!
We’re going to be at Brighton Mini Maker Faire, tomorrow Saturday 7th September!
Come see us and say hi! We’ll be demoing a totally rebuilt sand plotter, as well as selling Minimatrixes, Labs Cards, and Re:loads!
The faire is on from 10AM to 5:30 PM, at the Brighton Corn Exchange. Lots more details, and an opportunity to avoid lines and buy tickets ahead of time, can be found here.
Green LED matrixes are now available for the minimatrix! They’re a lot brighter than the red and orange ones, and even use less power to boot, so the minimatrix will last longer on a battery.
You can get your minimatrix here - or if you’re just after the LED matrixes, you can get them on their own here.
It’s what you’ve all - or at least some of you - have been waiting for: Minimatrix is now ready to go and officially for sale!
Initially it’s available in Red and Orange, and you can get your Minimatrix as a kit here for just $10, or fully assembled for just $15!
And don’t forget to pick up a remote to go with it.
Due to popular demand, I’ve done another run of the stencil8 tooling blocks with a fully populated grid of holes. If the regular stencil8 blocks aren’t for you, you can order a fully populated one for just a bit more.
Oops! Seems I forgot this all-important announcement in the rush of preparations for Maker Faire!
Re:load v2 is now in stock and shipping! The price is the same as ever, but v2 has a lot of improvements over v1:
- Most parts are now surface-mount and come pre-soldered, saving you effort
- Mounting holes and improved options for mounting the components on the Re:load for your custom case
- Increased voltage range, from 3.3 volts to 40 volts, with full reverse bias protection
- Option to power the Re:load from an external supply to support voltages from 0 to 60 volts
- Configurable potentiometer orientation, for more flexible enclosure options.
- Configurable FET placement, for more flexible enclosure options.
Get yours here!
One of the more popular items at our booth at ECMMF yesterday was the new Circuit Patterns Trading Cards. This is an idea I’ve been working on for a little while. Each card has a circuit diagram and a short description of a common circuit design pattern. Topics covered include analog, digital, and power electronics. They were hugely popular at the faire, and I even had people asking if they could buy whole decks.
There’s 32 cards in total, and from now on each kit we ship out will include one. If you don’t want to have to buy 130 kits to get the whole set, you can now buy a deck for just $10.
If you’ve got errata, ideas for improving them, or you’ve come up with something interesting to do with them (snap? top trumps?), let us know!
Yesterday was the Elephant and Castle Mini Maker Faire, and it was a blast! Thanks to everyone who showed up and said hi.
The new Circuit Patterns Trading Cards were well received - so much so I’m going to be offering whole packs for sale on Tindie in the very near future. Minimatrix was also a big hit - and if you’re one of the people who wanted one, add yourself to the notification list here and you’ll get an email when they’re ready to go, in about a week.
If you want to get in touch, you can email me at firstname.lastname@example.org.